Peter Berg's The Mosquito Bowl, the Netflix film about a football game played by Marines on Guadalcanal before the battle of Okinawa, is out in American cinemas, and the critics can't agree on it. One calls it among the best antiwar films he's seen. Others call it slick, macho and full of clichés.

A still from Peter Berg's war film The Mosquito Bowl. Photo: Kane Skennar / Netflix