
Amplified · Christian heavy
The cover of Brother, Sister (Tooth & Nail Records, 2006).
Cover art: mewithoutYou, Brother, Sister / Tooth & Nail Records, official cover
Brother, Sister — mewithoutYou
Sign in to rank 1–10.
Brother, Sister is the third album by mewithoutYou, the Philadelphia band that made its name on Tooth & Nail with shouted, anxious post-hardcore. It came out on September 26, 2006. It's 13 songs in a little under 44 minutes, and it followed Catch for Us the Foxes, their 2004 record. This is the album where they mostly put the yelling down and wrote something quieter, stranger and more lasting.
The story
The lineup was Aaron Weiss on vocals, his brother Michael Weiss and Christopher Kleinberg on guitar, Greg Jehanian on bass and Richard Mazzotta on drums. Jehanian had come in after Daniel Pishock left once Catch for Us the Foxes was done. They went back to Brad Wood, who produced and mixed the record at Seagrass Studio in Valley Village, California.
Sherwin Frias at Jesus Freak Hideout called it the album "this band's legacy will undoubtedly be built upon." He heard a group that was "no longer interested in making any attempts to fit the mold of a 'heavy' band" and had "almost entirely ditched their post-hardcore sensibilities." Brian Shultz at Punknews put it another way. In trading much of that old aggression for "atmospheric, brooding and yet dynamic indie rock," he wrote, they had quite arguably made their best record.
The opener tells you the change straight away. "Messes of Men" starts with a somber keyboard and the sound of rain, as Drew Ailes at Lambgoat noted, and Graeme Crawford at Cross Rhythms called it a "rain drenched brooding intro." Aaron Weiss, better known for speaking and shouting his lines, sings softly. Shultz said his voice was "surprisingly fragile when expressed in more hushed tones." The first line is "I do not exist, but faithfully insist."
Faith, but not a sermon
mewithoutYou were Christians on a Christian label, but this isn't a record that preaches at you. Shultz wrote that the band avoided "preachy overtones," and that the faith on the album arrives as "a vivid series of metaphors and occasional Bible storytelling, personal observances and confessions rather than directive fundamentalism." Crawford heard lyrics that were "poetic and mysterious, while clearly focussed on living for God."
Jon Young at Spin said you don't have to share Weiss's faith "to empathize with his feeling of being trapped between what he is and what he hopes to be." He also wrote that mewithoutYou "isn't a Christian group," at least not in the conventional sense. That doesn't really clash with Cross Rhythms. Both hear real faith, and Young just doesn't hear a typical Christian band. That tension is the point. The songs keep reaching for God and then admitting how messy the reaching is.
You can hear it all over. On "C-Minor," Weiss pleads, "do whatever makes me love you more." On the same song he admits he's "still technically a virgin after 27 years." Shultz heard Weiss either poking fun at exaggerated ideology or questioning his own practices, and Young said Weiss wonders whether that's a plus or a minus. The closer, "In a Sweater Poorly Knit," ends with Weiss singing "I do not exist / only You exist" over a fading harp. Shultz called that "a rather breathtaking ending."
"The Dryness and the Rain" and "O, Porcupine" both feature Jeremy Enigk of Sunny Day Real Estate. Shultz said Enigk's voice on the first of those recalled the post-reunion Sunny Day records, and that on "O, Porcupine" he arrives at the line "in darkness your light shines on me" before "a breathtaking, eyes-clenched emotional scream." Crawford also heard chants in Arabic, part of the experimenting he said pushed their sound further.
The sound
After the rainy opener, "The Dryness and the Rain" harks back to their older sound, Ailes wrote, and then breaks into a heavy, almost tribal drumbeat. "Wolf Am I! (And Shadow)" is the album's most direct and forceful song, with Weiss near-maniacally yelling, "one day, the water's gonna wash it away." Young quoted another line from it, the self-scolding "There I go again, so impressed by how well I put myself down."
Three short songs, "Yellow Spider," "Orange Spider" and "Brownish Spider," return to the same small melody with a few words swapped, as Shultz noted. They work as breathers. Some listeners will find them slight. Frias quoted the last of them: "Brownish spider, brownish leaf / Confirms my deepest held belief / No more spider, no more leaf / No more me, no more belief."
The heavier middle of the record is where the old band and the new one meet. Shultz heard Dischord snap and post-rock space together on "A Glass Can Only Spill What It Contains," and a rare Fugazi-like shout in the chorus of "In a Market Dimly Lit." Frias picked out accordion under that song and under the closer, and horns pushing "C-Minor" along. "Nice and Blue (pt. Two)" reworks "Nice and Blue" from their 2002 debut, [A-->B] Life, and keeps some of its melodies and lyrics.
Then comes the ending everyone points to. Ailes called "In a Sweater Poorly Knit" "the biggest highlight of the band's career." It starts quietly, then gathers drums, echoing guitars, and a harp. Crawford heard that harp on the fade. Shultz singled out the line "the trap I set for you seems to have caught my leg instead."
How it landed
Most critics were convinced. Frias, writing for readers who had already loved Catch for Us the Foxes, called it "one of the best albums of the year." Ailes gave it 9/10 and said there was "nothing on this CD that you'll want to skip over." Shultz treated it as their best work to date. The review at AbsolutePunk, now at chorus.fm, marked it "Highly Recommended" and said each album had gotten better than the last.
There were limits, and the writers admitted them. Frias said the record was "admittedly not for everyone," especially anyone still waiting for the bite of [A-->B] Life. Young thought Weiss "veers toward navel-gazing." The AbsolutePunk review warned that it wasn't catchy pop, and that some of the lyrics take work.
Our verdict
Those caveats are fair. The spider sketches are thin next to the full songs, and if you came for the old post-hardcore rush, this record will feel like a door closing. Weiss can talk in circles.
But Brother, Sister is the one to play someone who has never heard the band. The faith is honest without being a lecture. The quiet songs make the loud ones land, and "In a Sweater Poorly Knit" is as good a closing track as this scene produced. Start with "Messes of Men," then "A Glass Can Only Spill What It Contains," then that closer. For more on the band, see our mewithoutYou page.
9/10
If this story helped, you can help keep the paper going: Support the paper.




Notes
Notes
No notes on this story yet.
Sign in to comment